Follow the source trail (2)
How to read these
Each record below is held at The National Archives, which shows them with images and, where the paper allows, transcripts in two free teaching collections. We give the date, the catalogue reference and a short summary in our own words. A record shows that an accusation, a search or a defence happened. It does not show that anyone did magic. Where people were hurt or killed, we say so plainly.
Joan Guppie speaks up
December 1605 · TNA STAC 8/149/24
In December 1605 Joan Guppie described violence done to her by neighbours who suspected her of witchcraft, in a Bill: a legal document from someone claiming an injustice.[3]
A certificate for Joan Guppie
1606 · TNA E 163/17/5
In 1606 some inhabitants of South Perrot, Dorset, signed a certificate, in Latin, stating that Joan Guppie was not a witch.[3] The catalogue title of the 1606 certificate spells her name Jane Guppie, and the document is too damaged for a transcript.[3]
Two hogs and an indictment
25 March 1601 · TNA ASSI 35/45/3
A Latin indictment dated 25 March 1601 charged Agnes Whittenbery with bewitching to death two hogs belonging to Francis Combes.[7]
The confession of Agnes Samsone
29 January 1590 · TNA SP 52/47 f. 14i
Agnes Samsone was burned for witchcraft. Parts of her confession, dated 29 January 1590, survive at The National Archives.[3]
Thomas Paman owns up
28 February 1629 · TNA SP 16/161 f. 89
On 28 February 1629, at Newmarket, Thomas Paman confessed that he had pretended to be bewitched, and promised to make amends to the woman he had wronged.[7]
The boy who changed his story
16 July 1634 · TNA SP 16/271 f.227
During the trial of the Lancaster witches, a key witness, a young boy named Edmund Robinson, gave new evidence admitting that he had made up the accusations. His re-examination is dated 16 July 1634.[3] The Lancaster witches were a group of women tried together 20 years after the famous Pendle witch trials.[3]
The searchers’ certificate
2 July 1634 · TNA SP 16/271 f.15
Surgeons and midwives searched the bodies of the accused for supposed ‘witches’ marks’. A certificate from the Lancaster case is dated 2 July 1634.[3]
Denby stands by its neighbours
1674 · TNA ASSI 45/11/1/93
In 1674 dozens of neighbours in Denby, in the West Riding of Yorkshire, signed a statement defending Susanna Hinchcliffe and Anne Shillitoe and questioning the accusation against them.[7]
Found innocent, still in prison
20 October 1650 · TNA SP 18/183 f. 10
It was not only women. In a petition dated 20 October 1650, Henry Alcocke spoke up for Thomas Harvey, who had been accused of being a witch and found innocent, but was still in prison.[3]
Anne Piers and the townspeople
Date unknown · TNA SP 12/150 f. 96
Reputable townspeople testified that they did not believe Anne Piers to be a witch. The document is undated.[3]
Want these on paper for a class or reading group? Witch Trial Case Files gives each of ten National Archives records its own sheet, with an evidence matrix and a timeline of the law (paid download, $5.99 USD, A4 and US Letter).